《LAW AND MORALITY READINGS IN LEGAL PHILOSOPHY》

PART ONE:MORALITY AND THE RULE OF LAW3

Chapter 1:Positivism,Legal Ordering,and Morality3

Leviathan (1651)THOMAS HOBBES6

"Positivism and the Separation of Law and Morals" (1983);The Concept of Law (1961)H.L.A.HART28

Whitely v Chapel (1868) LR 4 QB 14761

The Morality of Law (1969)LON L.FULLER63

"Law's Ambitions for Itself" (1985);Law's Empire (1986)RONALD DWORKIN86

Riggs v Palmer (1889)104

Chapter 2:Adjudication110

Patriation Reference 125 DLR 3d 1110

Billy Budd,Sailor (1929)HERMAN MELVILLE121

"Of Creon and Captain Vere" (1976)ROBERT COVER129

Commonwealth v Aves 35 Mass.193 (1836)136

Sims's Case 7 Cush.285 (1851)139

"Judging the Fugitive Slave Acts" (1991)ANTHONY SEBOK148

"Charter Challenges:A Test Case for Theories of Law?" (1991)W.J.WALUCHOW153

"Natural Law and Legal Reasoning" (1994)JOHN FINNIS174

Chapter 3:Feminist Approaches to the Rule of Law192

"The Liberal State" (1989)CATHARINE A.MACKINNON192

"Foreword [to The Supreme Court 1986 Term]:Justice Engendered" (1987)MARTHA MINOW205

The Alchemy of Race and Rights (1991)PATRICIA WILLIAMS216

Lavallee v The Queen [1990] 555 CCC (3d) 97218

Chapter 4:Law and Values:Law as Protector of Individual Liberty233

On Liberty (1859)JOHN STUART MILL234

"Planning and the Rule of Law" (1994)F.A.VON HAYEK254

"What's Wrong with Negative Liberty" (1985)CHARLES TAYLOR266

"Morals and the Criminal Law" (1965)PATRICK DEVLIN276

Chapter 5:Law and Values:Law as a Tool of Democratic Self-Rule300

"Liberty and Moralism" (1977)RONALD DWORKIN300

"Democracy and the Rule of Law" (1987)ALLAN C.HUTCHINSON AND PATRICK MONAHAN309

Hofer v Hofer [1970] 13 DLR 3d 1336

PART TWO:SOME CONTEMPORARY ISSUES351

Chapter 6:Defining Family351

Canada (Attorney General) v Mossop [1993] 1 SCR 554352

Egan v Canada [1995] 2 SCR 513366

Bowers v Hardwick (1986)376

Michael M.v Gerald D.[1989] 491 U.S.110379

"Defining Family in Mossop v DSS:The Challenge of Anti-Essentialism and Interactive Discrimination for Human Rights Litigation" (1994)JODY FREEMAN380

Chapter 7:Civil Disobedience412

"Civil Disobedience" (1971)JOHN RAWLS413

"Civil Disobedience" (1979)RONALD DWORKIN434

"Letter from Birmingham City Jail" (1968)MARTIN LUTHER KING,JR453

Chapter 8:The Limits of the Legal Order469

"Speech from the Dock" (1962)NELSON MANDELA469

Queen's University Letter (1990)477

An Act Respecting the Future of Quebec (Bill 1) Introduced in the National Assembly of Quebec on September 7,1995479

Sovereign Injustice:Forcible Inclusion of James Bay Crees and Cree Territory into a Sovereign Quebec,Grand Council of the Crees (1995)485

Bertrand v Quebec [1995] 127 DLR (4th) 408498

Chapter 9:Speech,Hate Propaganda,and Pornography511

"Pornography and the Criminal Law" (1979)JOEL FEINBERG511

"A.Theory of Freedom of Expression" (1972)T.M.SCANLON517

"Talking about Hate Speech:A Rhetorical Analysis of American and Canadian Approaches to the Regulation of Hate Speech" (1994)MAYO MORAN536

R v Keegstra [1990] 3 SCR 697558

RAV v City of St Paul 112 S Ct 2538 (1992)599

"Criminal Responses to Hate-Motivated Violence:Is Bill C-41 Tough Enough?" (1996)MARTHA SHAFFER607

American Booksellers v Hudnut 771 F.2d 323 (7th Cir.1985)616

R v Butler [1992] 1 SCR 452622

Only Words (1993)CATHARINE A.MACKINNON646

"Two Concepts of Liberty" (1991)RONALD DWORKIN657

Native Women's Association of Canada v Canada [1992] 3 FC 192667

Chapter 10:Abortion680

"A Defence of Abortion" (1971)JUDITH JARVIS THOMSON680

"The Rights and Wrongs of Abortion:A Reply to Judith Jarvis Thomson" (1973)JOHN FINNIS698

Morgentaler,Smolling and Scott v The Queen [1988] 1 SCR 30726

"The Morgentaler Judgment:Constitutional Rights,Legislative Intention,and Institutional Design" (1992)LORRAINE WEINRIB745

Appendixes757

1The Canadian Charter of Rights and Freedoms757

2 An Overview of the Canadian Legal System:Division of Powers and Essentials of Procedure765

3 Glossary of Legal and Philosophical Terms770

SOURCES AND CREDITS775